When you consider a real estate investment, you might see legal terms in the property deed that limit how you can use the land or building. A restrictive covenant in a real estate deed is a legal clause that limits how you as the property owner can use, modify, or develop your property. These contractual limits imposed on the use or occupancy of real property can impact your investment plans and returns.
These covenants help maintain property values, preserve neighborhood character, and prevent uses that might affect surrounding properties. You’ll often find them in residential subdivisions and commercial developments where developers want to set consistent standards. Restrictive covenants can limit the use and development of property by prohibiting certain business activities, restricting architectural changes, or limiting rental arrangements.
It’s important to check these restrictions before you buy because they stay with the property even if ownership changes. Since a restrictive covenant can limit how you use the property, review these provisions carefully to avoid surprises that could affect your investment plans or reduce your property’s value.
Key Takeaways
- Restrictive covenants are legally binding clauses in deeds that permanently limit how you can use your property
- These restrictions protect neighborhood standards but can impact your investment flexibility and potential returns
- You should review all covenant terms before purchasing to ensure they fit your intended property use
Understanding Restrictive Covenants in Real Estate Deeds
Restrictive covenants are legal agreements that limit how you can use your property, and deed restrictions specifically appear in your property’s conveyance documents and stay with the land. These contractual limitations can affect your investment decisions and property development plans.
Definition and Purpose of Restrictive Covenants
A restrictive covenant is an enforceable clause in a real estate deed that limits how you can use your property as an owner or tenant. These agreements appear directly in your property deed or related documents.
The main purpose of restrictive covenants is to have all property owners follow the same set of rules. This creates uniformity within neighborhoods and developments and helps protect property values.
Developers place these restrictions on land to maintain certain standards within a subdivision. When you buy property with restrictive covenants, you agree to follow these rules even though you didn’t create them.
Common purposes include:
- Maintaining architectural consistency
- Preserving property values
- Controlling land use activities
- Protecting neighborhood character
How Restrictive Covenants Are Created and Enforced
Restrictive covenants are contractual limits imposed on the use or occupancy of real property. They can apply to a single tract of land or an entire subdivision and can limit your property’s use and development.
Creation Process:
- Developer includes restrictions in original subdivision plat
- Individual seller adds restrictions to specific deed
- Community establishes covenants through formal agreement
- Title company records restrictions with county recorder
Deed restrictions included in the conveyance will follow the land unless the restriction instrument provides otherwise. You can’t remove these restrictions simply by selling the property.
Neighbors can enforce restrictive covenants through civil lawsuits if you violate them, seeking damages or court orders to stop certain activities.
Types of Deed Restrictions
Restrictive covenants, sometimes called “deed restrictions,” “covenants, conditions and restrictions,” or “CCR’s” come in different forms that affect your property rights.
Architectural Restrictions:
- Building height limitations
- Exterior color requirements
- Construction material specifications
- Setback requirements from property lines
Use Restrictions:
- Residential-only designations
- Commercial activity prohibitions
- Home business limitations
- Livestock or farming restrictions
Maintenance Requirements:
- Landscaping standards
- Fence specifications
- Driveway materials
- Exterior maintenance obligations
Some restrictions allow changes if a certain percentage of affected landowners agree. If the restrictions don’t provide a way to change them, you usually need unanimous approval from all affected owners.
Role of Homeowners Associations and Property Owners
Many people think HOA rules and deed restrictions are the same, but they are different legal concepts. Your homeowners association enforces community rules through bylaws and regulations, while deed restrictions are permanently recorded in your property’s title history.
HOA Functions:
- Enforce community standards
- Collect dues and assessments
- Maintain common areas
- Modify rules through voting procedures
Property owners associations (POAs) work much like HOAs but usually have less authority. Both organizations can add restrictions beyond what appears in your deed.
Before buying land labeled as “unrestricted,” check the deed records carefully. A title commitment under Schedule B lists all restrictions with specific recorded instrument numbers.
Your title company should give you copies of all restrictive covenant documents during the purchase. Review these documents before closing, as violations can lead to legal disputes with neighbors or your HOA.
Legal and Practical Considerations of Restrictive Covenants
Property buyers can face legal challenges when restrictive covenants violate fair housing laws, and mortgage lenders may ask for covenant changes before loan approval. The landmark Shelley v. Kraemer case made it clear that courts cannot enforce racially discriminatory covenants, changing how these restrictions work in real estate today.
Implications for Property Buyers and Owners
When you buy property with restrictive covenants, you take on legal obligations that can limit your property rights for many years. These binding conditions in property deeds restrict how you can use, modify, or develop your land.
Financial Impact on Your Investment
- Compliance costs for architectural approvals
- Potential fines for covenant violations
- Reduced resale value if restrictions limit buyer pool
- Legal fees for covenant modifications or challenges
Be sure to review all covenant documents before closing. Some restrictions may prohibit home-based businesses, limit exterior changes, or require certain landscaping standards.
Due Diligence Requirements Your attorney should check the covenant’s enforceability and whether it still applies. Covenants must meet specific legal requirements including being negative in nature and relating to the land’s use.
Homeowners associations often enforce these covenants through architectural review committees, and you may need approval for changes like new fences or exterior paint colors.
Enforceability and Legal Challenges
Courts use strict legal criteria to decide if restrictive covenants remain valid and enforceable against current property owners. Your ability to challenge covenants depends on meeting certain legal standards.
Core Enforceability Requirements For covenants to bind you as a property owner, they must:
- Be negative restrictions rather than positive obligations
- Relate directly to the land
- Show clear intent to bind future owners
- Give proper notice to buyers
Common Legal Defenses You can challenge covenant enforcement using several legal arguments. If neighborhood conditions have changed, restrictions may be considered outdated under property law.
Courts may refuse to enforce covenants that no longer serve their original purpose. For example, commercial development in what was once a residential area can support these challenges.
Statutory Modification Options Many states offer procedures for modifying or removing covenants when restrictions become unreasonable. These processes usually require showing significant hardship or changed circumstances.
Your chances of successfully challenging covenants depend on proving the restriction no longer helps the intended parties or blocks reasonable property use.
Historical Context and Shelley v. Kraemer
The 1948 Supreme Court decision in Shelley v. Kraemer changed how restrictive covenants work in American real estate. This case established that state courts cannot enforce racially discriminatory covenants, even if they appear in valid deeds.
Constitutional Principles The Court ruled that enforcing racial restrictions in court counts as state action and violates the Fourteenth Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause. While private discrimination in covenant creation remained legal, government enforcement became unconstitutional.
This decision ended the legal enforceability of racial covenants while allowing other types of property restrictions. Courts cannot enforce covenants that discriminate based on race, religion, or national origin.
Modern Implications for Property Owners Even though racially restrictive language may still appear in old deeds, these provisions have no legal effect. Your property rights cannot be limited by discriminatory covenant language from the past.
Fair housing laws now provide additional protections beyond Shelley v. Kraemer, covering discrimination based on family status and disability.
Impact on Mortgages and Property Transactions
Mortgage lenders review restrictive covenants during underwriting since these restrictions can affect property value and marketability. Your loan approval may depend on resolving problematic covenant issues before closing.
Lender Requirements and Concerns Lenders check if covenants create financial risks that could impact loan security. Restrictive covenants that limit property use may reduce the collateral value for mortgage purposes.
Your lender may require title insurance that addresses covenant-related risks. Some financial institutions refuse loans on properties with overly restrictive or unclear covenants.
Transaction Complications Covenant disputes between buyers and sellers can delay real estate closings. You may need a legal opinion on covenant enforceability before moving forward with a purchase agreement.
Title Insurance Considerations Title companies review covenant records to spot potential enforcement issues. Your title policy may exclude coverage for certain covenant violations or challenges.
Standard title insurance often covers covenant-related title defects but may not protect against future enforcement actions by neighboring property owners.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most common types of restrictive covenants found in real estate deeds?
Building and architectural standards are the most common restrictive covenants, covering things like exterior paint colors, building materials, minimum square footage, and setback distances. Business operation prohibitions also appear frequently, restricting certain commercial activities, signage, operating hours, or high-traffic operations in residential areas. You may also see requirements for property maintenance, rules about parking recreational vehicles, limits on the number of occupants, and restrictions on fence heights, swimming pools, and satellite dishes.
What is the difference between restrictive covenants and deed restrictions in real estate?
Restrictive covenants, deed restrictions, and CC&Rs (covenants, conditions, and restrictions) all refer to the same concept, especially in homeowner associations and planned communities. Deed restrictions are usually recorded directly in the deed, while restrictive covenants may appear in separate documents but still bind future owners. Both terms describe legal obligations that transfer to new property owners, and the enforcement methods and legal effects are the same regardless of the term used.
Is it advisable to buy a property that has restrictive covenants attached to it?
Whether you should buy a property with restrictive covenants depends on your goals. Covenants can help maintain property values by keeping neighborhood standards and preventing incompatible uses, but they can also limit development opportunities or tenant options. It’s important to consider potential modification costs and how easily covenants can be changed before you buy.
Can restrictive covenants be amended or removed from a property deed, and if so, how?
You can sometimes amend restrictive covenants by paying the seller or affected neighbors, especially when the covenant benefits specific properties. Homeowners associations often require a certain percentage of members to vote for changes, and some communities need unanimous agreement. Courts may also remove covenants if they are outdated or conflict with current laws, and some covenants have sunset clauses that cause them to expire unless the community votes to keep them.
Are you looking to connect with property owners, landlords, and real estate investors?
Grow your business by connecting with property professionals with our cost-effective advertising options.
Master the art of real estate investing with The Real Estate Property Management Guide: Premium Edition – your comprehensive roadmap to successful property management.
Whether you’re a novice investor or seasoned professional, this guide covers everything from selecting the right investment properties to tenant management and property marketing.
The author, Jeff Rohde writing as Jeffrey Roark, is a professional with over 25 years of real estate experience. This Premium Edition includes the valuable bonus book Investment Real Estate Analysis: A Case Study to help you identify hidden opportunities and evaluate properties like a professional.
Learn practical, actionable strategies for both residential and commercial properties, from single-family homes to office buildings and shopping centers.
Don’t just buy property – learn how to manage it successfully and maximize your investment potential.
Grab your copy now from your favorite bookseller:
- Amazon (Basic Edition, does not include Investment Real Estate Analysis: A Case Study)
- Books2Read for Apple, Barnes & Noble, Kobo, Scribed, and 8 more sellers with both eBook and paperback options available (Premium Edition, includes Investment Real Estate Analysis: A Case Study)
- Payhip as a downloadable PDF (Premium Edition)
Ready to take your business to the next level?
- Subscribe to our newsletter
- Visit the learning center
- Learn more about our consulting services
