A right of first refusal in real estate gives an investor or buyer the legal right to purchase a property before the owner can sell it to anyone else. This contractual agreement activates when the property owner decides to sell, requiring them to offer the opportunity to match any legitimate third-party offer before completing the transaction.
Holding a first right of refusal provides priority purchasing rights, protecting interests in valuable properties for investment, family preservation, or business continuity. The arrangement requires the property owner to notify the holder when they receive an acceptable offer from another buyer, giving a specified time period to decide whether to match those terms and purchase the property.
ROFR agreements frequently appear in divorce settlements, family properties, commercial leases, and investment portfolios. Each context demands careful attention to timing, pricing mechanisms, and legal requirements.
Key Takeaways
- A first right of refusal grants priority to purchase a property before the owner can sell to other buyers
- The holder must match the terms of legitimate third-party offers within a specified timeframe to exercise their rights
- These agreements require precise legal language covering triggering events, notice procedures, and price determination methods
Understanding First Right of Refusal in Real Estate
A right of first refusal creates a contractual obligation that gives specific parties priority purchasing rights before properties reach the open market. This mechanism differs from other preferential purchase arrangements and follows a structured process when property owners decide to sell.
What Is a Right of First Refusal (ROFR)?
A right of first refusal in real estate is a contractual agreement that grants the legal right to purchase a property before the owner can sell it to anyone else. The ROFR clause activates only when the property owner receives a legitimate offer from a third party.
Unlike other purchase agreements, the holder has the right but not the obligation to buy. The holder can choose to match the third-party offer or decline the opportunity.
Key characteristics of ROFR include:
- Conditional activation – Only triggers when owner decides to sell
- Matching requirement – The holder must accept the same terms as the third-party offer
- Time limitations – The holder receives a specific period to respond, typically 30-90 days
- No purchase obligation – The holder can decline without penalty
The ROFR differs from standard purchase options because it doesn’t guarantee a sale will occur. If the property owner never sells, the right remains dormant indefinitely.
How the ROFR Clause Works in Property Transactions
When a property owner receives an offer, they must notify the ROFR holder before accepting any third-party proposal. This notification must include complete details about the proposed sale terms, purchase price, and closing conditions.
The holder then has a predetermined timeframe to decide whether to exercise the right. During this period, the property owner cannot negotiate with other buyers or modify the original offer terms.
The ROFR process follows these steps:
- Third-party offer received – Property owner gets legitimate purchase offer
- Formal notification – Owner sends written notice with offer details
- Review period – Holder evaluates terms and arranges financing if needed
- Decision deadline – Holder must respond within the contractual timeframe
- Transaction completion – Sale proceeds with holder or original third party
The ROFR mechanism ensures the holder receives genuine purchase opportunities at market-driven prices. The holder cannot negotiate different terms but gains access to properties that might not otherwise be available.
Key Differences Between Right of First Refusal and Right of First Offer (ROFO)
The distinction between ROFR and ROFO determines when and how a buyer can purchase the property. These mechanisms serve different strategic purposes and offer varying levels of control.
Right of First Refusal (ROFR):
- Activates after third-party offers are received
- Requires matching existing offer terms exactly
- Provides market-validated pricing
- Offers reactive purchasing opportunity
Right of First Offer (ROFO):
- Activates before property goes to market
- Allows negotiation of purchase terms
- Uses fair market value pricing
- Provides proactive purchasing opportunity
ROFO gives the holder earlier intervention in the sales process, while ROFR ensures the ability to match competitive market offers. ROFO typically requires offers at fair market value, while ROFR allows the holder to benefit from potentially favorable third-party pricing.
The choice between these mechanisms depends on risk tolerance and market strategy. ROFO provides more control but may result in higher purchase prices, while ROFR offers potential savings but less certainty about activation.
Important Considerations for ROFR Clauses
ROFR clauses require careful attention to trigger mechanisms, notification procedures, and timeline specifications to avoid disputes. The impact on property values and transaction flexibility varies significantly between buyers, sellers, and different property contexts like leases or family transfers.
Trigger Events and Third-Party Offers
Clearly define what events activate the ROFR clause to prevent disputes. The most common trigger is when the property owner receives a legitimate third-party offer from an outside buyer.
Valid Third-Party Offers must meet specific criteria to trigger the ROFR. The offer should be:
- Made in good faith by an unrelated party
- Financially qualified and capable of closing
- Include specific price and terms
- Not structured to circumvent the ROFR
Some contracts specify minimum offer amounts to avoid triggering the ROFR for nominal transactions. Others exclude certain types of transfers like gifts to family members or business reorganizations.
Bona Fide Offer Requirements prevent property owners from creating fake offers to manipulate ROFR holders. Contracts should require proof of the buyer’s financial capacity and earnest money deposits.
The timing of ROFR activation matters. Some agreements trigger when the owner decides to sell, while others only activate upon receiving an acceptable offer.
Notice Requirements and Timeframes
ROFR contracts must specify exact notification procedures to ensure enforceability. Proper notice delivery methods reduce disputes and protect both parties’ rights.
Acceptable Delivery Methods typically include:
- Certified mail with return receipt
- Email with read receipt confirmation
- Personal delivery with signed acknowledgment
- Registered mail to last known address
Require multiple delivery methods for critical notices. The contract must specify which address to use if the ROFR holder has moved.
Response Timeframes vary by property type and complexity. Residential properties typically allow 30-60 days for response, while commercial properties may require 60-90 days for due diligence.
Timeframes should account for:
- Financing arrangement time
- Property inspection periods
- Legal review requirements
- Holiday and weekend exclusions
The clock starts from proper notice delivery, not when the ROFR holder reads it. Do not extend deadlines without written agreement from the property owner.
Benefits and Drawbacks for Buyers and Sellers
ROFR arrangements create different advantages and challenges depending on your position in the transaction. Understanding these pros and cons helps with negotiation and contract drafting.
Benefits for ROFR Holders:
- Guaranteed first opportunity to purchase
- Protection against losing desired properties
- Ability to match market-rate offers
- No upfront option fees required
Drawbacks for ROFR Holders:
- No control over timing of sale opportunities
- Must accept all terms of third-party offers
- Risk of losing rights through missed deadlines
- No guarantee the property will ever be sold
Benefits for Property Owners:
- Maintains control over sale timing and terms
- Creates potential backup buyer option
- May command premium prices from motivated ROFR holders
- Provides negotiating leverage in some situations
Drawbacks for Property Owners:
- Reduces pool of potential buyers
- Delays transaction closing timelines
- May decrease property marketability
- Creates ongoing legal obligations and notice requirements
ROFR in Leases, Family Property, and Share Transfers
Different property contexts require specialized ROFR approaches. Commercial leases, family properties, and share transfers each present unique considerations for structuring these agreements.
Commercial Lease Applications often include ROFR clauses that protect tenant businesses from displacement. Specify in your lease whether the ROFR applies to the entire building or only to the occupied space.
Tenants gain business continuity protection, while landlords may prefer the stability of existing tenant relationships over unknown buyers.
Family Property Transfers commonly use ROFR clauses to keep real estate within family ownership. These agreements often span multiple generations and require careful estate planning coordination.
Address inheritance scenarios, tax implications, and valuation methods for family transfers. Use specific language in ROFR clauses to ensure they remain effective during property transfers.
Share Transfer Applications become relevant when properties are held in partnerships, LLCs, or corporations. The ROFR may apply to membership interests rather than direct property ownership.
Specify in your contracts whether the ROFR covers percentage ownership transfers, voting rights, or economic interests. Share-based ROFRs often include anti-dilution provisions and drag-along rights.
Board members typically must approve business entity ROFRs, and these agreements may use different valuation methods than direct property sales.
Are You Looking To Connect With Property Owners, Landlords, and Real Estate Investors?
Grow your business by connecting with property professionals with our cost-effective advertising options.
Master the art of real estate investing with The Real Estate Property Management Guide: Premium Edition – your comprehensive roadmap to successful property management.
Whether you’re a novice investor or seasoned professional, this guide covers everything from selecting the right investment properties to tenant management and property marketing.
The author, Jeff Rohde writing as Jeffrey Roark, is a professional with over 25 years of real estate experience. This Premium Edition includes the valuable bonus book Investment Real Estate Analysis: A Case Study to help you identify hidden opportunities and evaluate properties like a professional.
Learn practical, actionable strategies for both residential and commercial properties, from single-family homes to office buildings and shopping centers.
Don’t just buy property – learn how to manage it successfully and maximize your investment potential.
Grab your copy now from your favorite bookseller:
- Amazon (Basic Edition, does not include Investment Real Estate Analysis: A Case Study)
- Books2Read for Apple, Barnes & Noble, Kobo, Scribed, and 8 more sellers with both eBook and paperback options available (Premium Edition, includes Investment Real Estate Analysis: A Case Study)
- Payhip as a downloadable PDF (Premium Edition)
Ready to take your business to the next level?
- Subscribe to our newsletter
- Visit the learning center
- Learn more about our consulting services
