Setting Reasonable Standards for Tenant Selection: A Guide for Landlords

setting reasonable standards for tenant selection

Are you a landlord looking for ways to ensure that your rental property is filled with great tenants? Setting reasonable standards for tenant selection can be an arduous task, but it’s worth the effort.

In this guide, we’ll cover everything from assessing the rental market and setting standards to understanding the requirements of fair housing laws and going through the tenant application process. We’ll also discuss the role of credit checks in tenant screening and making final decisions on tenants, as well as how to work with an experienced property manager to set standards and ensure compliance.

Assessing the Rental Market and Setting Standards

When assessing the rental market, you should consider a variety of factors such as local demand, rent prices, and competition. This will help them develop an appropriate set of standards for prospective tenants.

Be sure to also evaluate their own property to determine which amenities and features are most desirable in the current market. Additionally, they should familiarize themselves with applicable state and federal laws so they can select tenants who meet their criteria while remaining compliant with legal requirements.

Understanding the Requirements of Fair Housing Laws

Photo by Clay Banks on Unsplash

It is essential that landlords understand the requirements of fair housing laws, which protect tenants from discrimination based on race, color, religion, national origin, sex, disability, and more. Be mindful to not make any selections or decisions regarding tenant applications which may violate these laws. If an owner has multiple rental properties in different locations they must also comply with local and state-specific regulations regarding tenant selection.

Creating a Tenant Application Process

Creating a tenant application process is essential to select the best possible tenants for a rental property. During this process, landlords should be sure to check potential renter references and conduct background checks including credit reports.

Landlords also need to create and apply consistent standards when assessing applications from prospective tenants. This will help ensure that only qualified applicants are accepted – those who have both the financial means and good character traits necessary for successful tenancy.

Collecting and Evaluating Tenant Information

The next step in the tenant selection process is collecting and evaluating information from potential tenants. Consider a variety of factors, such as prior rental history, employment and income level, references, credit score, and criminal background.

Beyond simply collecting this information, it’s important to evaluate each prospective tenant objectively to make sure they meet the standards set by the landlord. Additionally, landlords must take into account any state or federal fair housing regulations when making their decisions. This can help ensure that the selection process is both fair and compliant with legal requirements.

The Role of Credit Checks in Tenant Screening

Credit checks provide insight into an applicant’s ability to pay rent on time. A good credit score is often seen as an indicator of financial responsibility and reliability. However, landlords should take other factors into consideration when making their decisions, such as rental history and references.

Additionally, landlords must be mindful not to discriminate on any basis prohibited by fair housing laws. Credit checks can provide useful information when evaluating tenants, but should not be the sole deciding factor in tenant selection.

Making Final Decisions on Tenants

Once all of the necessary information has been gathered and evaluated, it is time to make a final decision on prospective tenants. Consider the relevant factors when weighing their options, such as rental history, income level, credit score, and criminal background.

Making sure that all decisions regarding tenant selection are made objectively and without bias can help ensure that owners find reliable tenants who will adhere to their rental policies and comply with applicable state and federal regulations. This will help to ensure landlords have successful long-term tenants who help keep their rental properties in good condition.

Working with an Experienced Property Manager

A property manager brings a wealth of knowledge to the table, from creating effective rental criteria to providing insight into how local landlord-tenant laws apply to tenants.

They are also well-versed in legal implications related to fair housing practices, so landlords can be sure their standards are compliant with state and federal regulations. Working with a property manager can provide peace of mind that all tenant screenings and selections are conducted fairly and accurately. That’s why many landlords turn to them for help establishing reasonable standards for tenant selection and screening.


If you’re looking to further your knowledge on managing rental property, get your copy of Achieving Financial Success as a Property Manager: An Insider’s Guide today. This comprehensive guide will provide you with all the information and strategies you need to become an expert in rental property management. Don’t miss out – grab yours now from your favorite bookseller:

  • Amazon 
  • Books2Read for Apple, Barnes & Noble, Kobo, Scribed, and 8 more sellers with both eBook and paperback options available
  • Payhip as a PDF

Content created by J. Scott Digital freelance copywriting services. Featured photo by Alexander Grey on Unsplash.